Trauma Informed Training

Same Family, Different Childhood: What ACE Research Tells Us About Siblings

Same Family, Different Childhood: What ACE Research Tells Us About Siblings

When we talk about Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs), we often focus on the individual child: what happened to them, how it affected them and what support they may need.

But childhood does not happen in isolation.

Brothers and sisters may be living alongside the same parental alcohol misuse, domestic abuse, neglect, mental illness, family breakdown or violence. They may hear the same arguments, live under the same roof and apparently experience the same family circumstances.

Yet they do not necessarily experience the same childhood.

A substantial scoping review by Ben Donagh and colleagues at the University of Birmingham examined what research tells us about siblings living with ACEs. The researchers searched 12 databases, initially identifying 11,469 papers, before reviewing 148 empirical studies that met their inclusion criteria.

What emerges is a much more complex picture of childhood adversity than an ACE score alone can capture.

Sibling relationships can protect children. They can expose children to additional harm. Older siblings may sacrifice their own needs to protect younger children. Brothers and sisters may remember the same family very differently. And, importantly, when one child is identified as experiencing adversity, we should not assume that their siblings are unaffected.

Siblings can be a powerful protective factor

Sibling relationships are unusual because they can be among the longest relationships people experience.

The paper notes that around 85–90% of children grow up with at least one brother or sister. Sibling relationships can provide companionship, emotional security and opportunities to develop social skills and identity. But they can also involve rivalry, conflict and harm.

Under difficult family circumstances, that relationship may become particularly important.

The review found evidence that positive sibling relationships can reduce some of the impact of childhood adversity. Siblings may provide emotional support, companionship and continuity when other relationships in a child’s life are unstable.

Some children experiencing physical abuse, for example, were found to disclose what was happening to a sibling before telling anyone else.

That makes intuitive sense.

When adults feel unsafe, unpredictable or unavailable, another child living inside the same family system may be the only person who fully understands what is happening.

The sibling does not need an explanation of why everyone suddenly becomes quiet when a parent comes home. They already know.

They do not need to be told why their brother is listening for footsteps on the stairs.

They may be listening too.

In this way, sibling relationships can become an important source of resilience.

But there is another side to this.

The child who becomes the protector

One of the strongest patterns identified in the review concerned birth order.

Across multiple studies, older brothers and sisters were found to take responsibility for protecting younger siblings from adversity. They might comfort them, remove them from dangerous situations, distract them, look after them when a parent is unavailable or try to prevent them witnessing what is happening.

In some families, the older child effectively begins to function as another parent.

This is often described as parentification.

The review found substantial evidence that older siblings can buffer younger children against adversity and, in some circumstances, protect them from further abuse.

From the outside, this child can look remarkably capable.

They may be:

  • mature for their age
  • highly responsible
  • protective of younger children
  • practical in a crisis
  • reluctant to ask adults for help
  • unusually independent.

Adults may even praise them for it.

But competence is not the same thing as absence of need.

The research reviewed by Donagh and colleagues suggests that this protective role can come at considerable cost. Older siblings may experience greater exposure to adversity, suppress or mask their own needs and carry a disproportionate burden of responsibility.

The review therefore makes an important point for professionals: while considerable attention is understandably paid to vulnerable younger children, substantially less attention may be given to the older child who is protecting them.

This matters because the apparently resilient child can become the overlooked child.

Their coping strategy may effectively be:

Someone has to cope, so it will be me.

And because that strategy works — at least in the short term — adults may fail to notice its cost.

Two children can experience the same event differently

Another important finding challenges a common assumption about siblings.

When brothers and sisters grow up in the same household, we sometimes talk as though they had the same childhood.

They did not necessarily.

The review found that even where siblings had been exposed to the same traumatic events, they could perceive those events differently and respond to them differently.

Possible explanations identified in the research included:

  • age
  • gender
  • degree of exposure
  • individual perception
  • emotional regulation
  • differences in memory.

In one study concerning parental alcoholism, siblings could even disagree over whether their parent had been an alcoholic.

This is an important principle for trauma-informed practice.

Shared circumstances do not automatically produce shared experience.

Imagine two children living with an unpredictable parent.

One child may become hypervigilant, constantly monitoring the parent’s mood.

Another may spend as much time as possible outside the house.

One may become compliant and helpful.

Another may become angry and oppositional.

One may remember the parent primarily as frightening.

Another may remember periods of affection and defend them fiercely.

None of these differences necessarily tells us which child’s account is “correct”.

Human beings do not simply record experiences like cameras. We experience events through our developmental stage, temperament, relationship with the people involved, sense of danger, previous experiences and the meaning we attach to what is happening.

This is one reason practitioners need to be cautious about assuming that one sibling can tell us how another sibling has been affected.

If one child is affected, ask about the others

The review also identifies an important safeguarding implication.

When one child in a family has experienced abuse or maltreatment, there is evidence that their brothers and sisters are at increased risk of experiencing adversity themselves.

One study included in the review examined 870 sibling pairs and found that around 59% reported that both siblings had experienced maltreatment.

But siblings do not have to experience the abuse directly to be affected.

They may also experience vicarious trauma through witnessing what happens to a brother or sister.

A child who repeatedly hears another child being assaulted, witnesses violence against them or lives with the fear of what might happen to them is not simply an uninvolved observer.

The review therefore argues that when one child presents with childhood adversity, services should consider the other siblings.

That does not mean automatically referring every child in a family for treatment.

The researchers are quite explicit about this distinction.

The more appropriate response is to consider and assess each sibling individually, rather than assuming either that everybody needs intervention or that everybody else is fine.

That is a subtle but important difference.

Siblings are not always protective

There is a danger, however, in romanticising sibling relationships.

One of the most striking findings in the review is the amount of research concerning siblings causing harm to one another.

Nearly 40% of the papers included in the review considered sibling violence and abuse. The authors report that several studies identified sibling abuse as one of the most common forms of violence occurring within the home.

Yet it is frequently minimised.

Parents may describe repeated aggression as:

“They’re always fighting.”

“It’s just sibling rivalry.”

“Boys will be boys.”

“She knows how to wind him up.”

“They give as good as they get.”

The problem is that describing something as sibling rivalry does not tell us whether the relationship is actually safe.

The review found repeated evidence that sibling violence and abuse can be normalised or dismissed by parents despite its potential impact.

This gives practitioners an important question to ask.

Rather than simply asking:

“Do these siblings fight?”

we may need to ask:

What actually happens between them?

Is there fear?

Is there coercion?

Is one child consistently more powerful?

Can the other child escape?

Is injury occurring?

Does one child control or intimidate the other?

Is the behaviour escalating?

What happens after adults intervene?

The word sibling should not cause us to apply a lower threshold for taking harmful behaviour seriously.

Children may reproduce what they learn

The review also discusses research using social learning theory to understand sibling aggression.

Children exposed to aggressive behaviour from parents may learn that aggression is a legitimate way of managing conflict, power or frustration.

That does not mean that a child who harms a sibling should simply be excused because they have experienced adversity.

Understanding behaviour and accepting behaviour are not the same thing.

But it does change the question.

Instead of asking only:

“How do we stop this child behaving badly?”

we can also ask:

“What has this child learned about what people do when they are frightened, angry, powerless or frustrated?”

That distinction matters.

Trauma-informed practice is not about removing boundaries or consequences. It is about understanding what may be driving behaviour so that our response does not inadvertently reinforce the same threat, shame or aggression that contributed to it in the first place.

Sibling sexual abuse is particularly easy to minimise

The review also examines sibling sexual abuse.

The research it considered associated sibling sexual abuse with anxiety, depression, post-traumatic stress, family estrangement and later difficulties with relationships and intimacy.

A particular problem is accessibility: unlike abuse involving somebody outside the household, siblings may have continuing access to one another, potentially allowing the abuse to continue over long periods.

Even relatively small age differences can create significant differences in physical, emotional or developmental power.

The review also found repeated evidence of adults minimising or normalising sexual behaviour between siblings, sometimes interpreting it as harmless curiosity or responding to disclosure with disbelief.

At the same time, the authors identify an important research difficulty: there is no universally accepted definition of sibling sexual abuse, which makes prevalence and comparison between studies difficult.

That nuance matters.

We should neither pathologise normal childhood sexual curiosity nor minimise coercive, harmful or developmentally inappropriate behaviour.

Context, consent, developmental difference, coercion, fear and power matter.

Trauma can bring siblings together — or drive them apart

Perhaps the most important message from the paper is that there is no single “sibling response” to adversity.

Positive sibling relationships can provide extraordinary support.

Poor sibling relationships can compound trauma.

Children may compete for scarce parental attention.

One sibling may resent the attention another receives because of their difficulties.

An older child may feel trapped by responsibility.

A younger child may later have little understanding of what the older child protected them from.

Children may develop radically different interpretations of their parents and their childhood.

And those differences may persist long after everyone has left the family home.

This helps explain something that can otherwise be puzzling in adult families: why brothers and sisters can tell apparently incompatible stories about growing up together.

The fact that one sibling remembers a parent as loving does not automatically invalidate another sibling’s recollection of fear or neglect.

The fact that one child appeared unaffected does not mean they were unaffected.

And the fact that one sibling protected another does not mean that relationship was psychologically uncomplicated.

What does this mean for professionals?

For anyone working with children, families or adults affected by childhood adversity, this research suggests several useful shifts in thinking.

Look sideways as well as upwards.

When we explore childhood experiences, we often focus on the child’s relationship with parents or caregivers. Sibling relationships can be equally important.

Do not assume the capable child is the unaffected child.

Responsibility, independence and emotional self-sufficiency may sometimes represent adaptation rather than wellbeing.

Ask about every child’s experience individually.

The presence of adversity in one child’s life should raise curiosity about siblings without assuming that they have experienced it in exactly the same way.

Do not automatically dismiss sibling aggression as rivalry.

Look at power, coercion, frequency, fear and impact.

Recognise sibling relationships as potential sources of resilience.

Where relationships are safe and supportive, preserving sibling connections may matter enormously, particularly when children are removed from parental care. The review specifically identifies this as an issue statutory services should consider.

And perhaps most importantly:

Do not assume that children raised in the same family had the same childhood.

A limitation worth remembering

This paper is a scoping review rather than evidence that any single sibling pattern will occur in a particular family.

The authors also identify significant limitations in the evidence base. Their review had to reduce its planned publication period from 1995–2019 to 2005–2019 because of the volume of research. Most studies investigated individual ACEs rather than adversity collectively, some forms of adversity received substantially more research attention than others, and more than half of the included papers offered no theoretical explanation for their findings.

There is also relatively little research examining different forms of sibling relationships such as step-, half- and adoptive siblings.

And the document discussed here was published on medRxiv as a preprint, meaning that this version had not itself undergone peer review.

So the findings should inform our curiosity rather than become another checklist.

The bigger lesson

One of the risks of ACE awareness is that a complicated developmental history becomes reduced to a number.

Four ACEs.

Six ACEs.

Eight ACEs.

Those numbers can be valuable at a population level, but they tell us relatively little about the lived experience of an individual child.

Sibling research demonstrates why.

Two children can live through the same parental separation, the same alcohol misuse and the same domestic violence.

One may hide.

One may fight.

One may protect.

One may become prematurely independent.

One may cling tightly to relationships.

One may leave the family as soon as possible.

And one may have spent years protecting the other so successfully that the younger sibling never fully understood what the older child experienced.

The household may have been shared.

The adversity may have been shared.

The childhood was not necessarily the same.

That is why good trauma-informed practice requires more than asking what happened in this family?

We also need to ask:

What did it mean to this particular child — and what did they have to become in order to live through it?


Research discussed: Donagh, B., Taylor, J., al Mushaikni, M. & Bradbury-Jones, C., Sibling Experiences of Adverse Childhood Experiences: A Scoping Review. The supplied version was posted as a medRxiv preprint in February 2022.

About the author

Mindschange administrator

Leave a Reply